Books Are for Talking Too!, fourth edition

by Jane L. Gebershttps://soundingyourbest.com/

ElaGrades Pre-K–5

Books Are for Talking Too!: Speech-Language Resource for Picture Books

Books Are for Talking Too! is a 551-page professional resource written by speech-language pathologist Jane L. Gebers that provides detailed guidance for using over 250 picture books to develop oral communication and literacy skills in children PreK-5. The curriculum focuses on targeted skill development through carefully analyzed children's literature rather than serving as a complete ELA program.

Best for

Speech-language pathologists, special education teachers, and educators seeking targeted remediation activities to supplement core ELA programs for specific skill development

Evaluation Criteria

3 strengths · 2 concerns · 3 neutral · 1 insufficient evidence

Teacher TrainingStrength

The curriculum provides extensive professional guidance but is written primarily for trained educators and speech-language pathologists.

Written by a speech-language pathologist for 'professional educators and service providers,' includes professional jargon that is explained, and provides detailed instructional methods

Direct InstructionStrength

The curriculum provides explicit, step-by-step methods and activities for teaching targeted skills with each recommended book.

Each book entry includes specific 'Method' sections with detailed instructions, and activities 'build upon one another' with clear sequential steps

Vocabulary BuildingStrength

Vocabulary development is explicitly targeted as one of the core skill areas throughout the program.

Target Skills sections consistently include 'Vocabulary' as a heading, and methods include activities like expanding vocabulary and using metaphors and similes

Text ComplexityConcern

The curriculum deliberately uses picture books with minimal text, which may limit exposure to grade-appropriate complex texts.

Gebers specifically recommends 'picture books' with 'minimal text' for use in 'brief sessions,' though books are graded for levels 1-5+

Writing InstructionConcern

The curriculum focuses on oral communication and reading skills with limited emphasis on structured writing instruction.

The program targets oral communication skills, articulation, and language literacy, with only occasional extended activities involving drawing or crafts

Knowledge RichNeutral

The curriculum indexes books by topic explorations including cities, cultures, and family relationships, but systematic domain knowledge building is not the primary focus.

Books are indexed under topics like 'Cities; New York City; Culture and history, Hispanic; Family relationships' and themes like seasons, pets, and music

Systematic PhonicsNeutral

The curriculum includes targeted phonological awareness activities but is designed to supplement, not replace, systematic phonics programs.

Section 2 provides phonological awareness activities like clapping syllables and initial sound awareness, with the author stating it's 'not intended to replace such a program, but rather to provide targeted activities to supplement'

Whole Books Vs ExcerptsNeutral

The curriculum recommends complete picture books, though it focuses on books with minimal text for brief instructional sessions.

Gebers recommends picture books because she believes illustrations are critical, and most recommended books have minimal text for use in brief sessions

Retrieval PracticeInsufficient Evidence

The curriculum does not emphasize retrieval practice or spaced review of previously learned content.

No mention of review cycles, quizzes, or systematic retrieval of vocabulary or skills in the detailed program description

Review Sources

cathyduffy

Cathy Duffy

Key Facts
GradesGrades Pre-K–5
SubjectEla
PedagogyTraditional
Faith-BasedNo
Pricing$61.95 at Amazon.com

Looking for something different?

If none of these options feel right, explore a non-traditional approach. Pallas Center offers a unique curriculum, or design your own with Palladay.

Data sources: cathyduffy