TOPS Learning Systems

Name: TOPS Learning Systems
Brand: TOPS Learning Systems, Inc.http://www.topscience.org

by TOPS Learning Systems, Inc.http://www.topscience.org

ScienceGrades 3–12

TOPS Learning Systems: Experiment-Based Topic Modules

TOPS Learning Systems offers over 40 individual topic-based books focusing on hands-on science experiments for grades 3-12. Each book addresses a single scientific concept like electricity, magnetism, or heat through practical activities requiring minimal equipment.

Best for

Homeschool families or teachers seeking reliable, low-cost hands-on science experiments organized by topic, particularly those wanting supplement materials for specific science concepts

Evaluation Criteria

1 strength · 3 neutral · 3 insufficient evidence

Hands On IntegrationStrength

The curriculum is heavily hands-on focused with practical experiments that consistently work and require minimal equipment.

Reviewer was 'amazed when every one of the experiments worked' and notes they require 'minimal equipment and expense' with 'clearly numbered and illustrated instructions'

Knowledge RichNeutral

The curriculum appears to build content knowledge through topic-focused modules, with reviewer noting it takes students to a 'deeper level of learning' that prepares them for challenging courses.

Each book addresses single topics in depth, and the reviewer states the approach 'really prepares them for challenging science courses' compared to other experiment books

Teacher TrainingNeutral

Books include teacher guidance with objectives, troubleshooting tips, and extension activities, though no formal professional development mentioned.

Each activity includes 'information for the teacher' with 'objective, some details that will help the experiment work out, answers, extension activities'

Direct InstructionNeutral

The curriculum provides teacher information including objectives and background details, but appears primarily activity-based rather than direct instruction focused.

Teacher materials include 'the objective, some details that will help the experiment work out, answers, extension activities' but emphasis is on hands-on activities

Ngss AlignmentInsufficient Evidence

No evidence provided regarding NGSS alignment or adherence to specific science standards.

No mention of standards alignment in the review materials

Retrieval PracticeInsufficient Evidence

Some books include data recording and math applications, but no clear evidence of systematic retrieval practice or review.

Reviewer mentions 'data recording' in some books and 'math applications' especially for older levels, but no mention of quizzes or review activities

Scientific VocabularyInsufficient Evidence

Limited evidence regarding explicit vocabulary instruction, though topic-focused approach likely introduces relevant terminology.

Books cover specific scientific topics like 'oxidation,' 'magnetism,' and 'pressure' but no mention of explicit vocabulary instruction methods

Sources: cathyduffyreviews.com